With Halloween almost here, have some fun with these Halloween Would You Rather Questions I have created. There is a free printable version that you can download and print out and I think they would be great to pop into treat bags or even just handed out with candies to trick-or-treaters! There is also a smaller amount of the questions here as well in case you don’t want the full printable set.
When I create Would You Rather questions, I really try to make the options different from each other so you have to make more interesting value judgements. Plus I think it leads to much more discussion with the people you are playing this game with!
Print a few copies, cut the cards, and have people read out a card for others to answer.

How to play:
- Read the would you rather question out loud and have people answer which option they would choose.
- Feel free to add more context yourself to the options if people are asking more follow-up questions.
Halloween Would You Rather Questions
- Have a black cat that can talk as a pet OR be able to turn into a bat?
- Go trick or treating alone but you get 1000 candies OR have a holiday in Transylvania?
- Own a flying broomstick OR be able to walk through walls like a ghost?
- Have a Halloween Party on a boat OR be able to see and talk to ghosts?
- Look slightly like a werewolf but be really good at basketball OR have all of October off work/school?
- Have Halloween be once a month OR own a costume shop?
- Be able to tell other people’s fortunes OR have a never-ending bag of candy corn?
- Have a corn maze in your backyard Or stay up till midnight watching horror movies?
- Never eat candy again OR dress as a clown for all of October?
- Be in a bath and get covered in spiders for 5 minutes OR Live in a pyramid in Egypt for a month?
There are more even better Halloween Would You Rather Questions included in the the free printable version you can get below!

Get The Halloween Would You Rather Printable Questions
Get my FREE Halloween Would You Rather Questions – print, cut, play, and laugh in minutes. Just click “Click to Subscribe” to have it sent to your inbox.
Click to subscribe and I’ll email your free download link right away.
Instant download. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
How to print at actual size
1. Open the Print dialog (Ctrl + P on Windows or ⌘ + P on Mac).
2. Under Page Sizing or Scale, select “Actual Size” or set Scale to 100 %.
3. Make sure “Fit to Page” or “Shrink to Fit” is turned off and Borderless printing is disabled.
4. Confirm the printer’s paper size matches your card (A5, US Letter, 5×7, etc.).
5. Click Print.
More fun
See more of our fun Halloween free printables!
- Halloween Charades With Free Printable Cards
- Halloween Mad Libs Style Free Printable
- Hey Boo Free Printable Halloween Favor Tags
- Free Halloween Favor Tags Printable
- Free Printable Halloween Gift Tags
- Broom Jokes (not made with AI!)
